Free shipping over $35 | Free returns




$ to $ Go


& Up
& Up

Special Feature



Sort By
101 items
1 out of 5
Jams, Jellies & Preserves
You can't have a peanut butter and jelly without the jelly. Shop jams, jellies, and preserves at and stock up on the best brands!

Why preserve your old pantry routine when you could satisfy your Smucker's habit here instead? Because honestly, our selection of sweet fruit spreads is second to none. We've got jelly in just about every jelly flavor you could ask for, from good old strawberry and grape jelly to Goya guava jelly, Smucker's apple jelly, and beyond. Looking for lemon jelly? Try Dickinson's Lemon Curd. Thinking about roasting a rack of lamb? Mint jelly might be more your speed. There's a jelly for every occasion, really.


If you like something with a little more texture on your peanut butter and jelly, check out our selection of jams and preserves. We've got jam from brands like Welch's, Stonewall Kitchen, and St. Dalfour. And we have tons of different preserve options if you're all in on chunks of fruit — fig preserves, strawberry preserves, and lots of other preserves from brands like Smucker's and Bonne Maman. Maybe you're more of an marmalade person, but don't worry, because we've got you covered there too. Why stop at Smucker's jelly and Smucker's jam when Smucker's also makes a Sweet Orange Marmalade?


Meanwhile, definitely check out our pepper jelly selection if you want a savory jelly instead. Stonewall Kitchen's Red Pepper Jelly is great with cheese and crackers, on a grilled cheese, or even for dipping fries mixed with a little mayo. Want a pepper jelly with a kick? Try hot pepper jelly from brands like Tabasco and Braswell's — it makes for a peanut butter and jelly that will change the way you see peanut butter and jelly forever. Once you realize how much you can do with pepper jelly and hot pepper jelly, you'll always want to have them around.

So yeah — from Smucker's to smaller brands you haven't heard of yet, our selection of jams, jelly, and preserves is pretty great. And with our free shipping over $35 and 2-day delivery on thousands of essentials, why get your Smucker's strawberry jam, Bonne Maman peach preserves, or Tabasco pepper jelly anywhere else? We've got all your pantry essentials covered, plus the rest of your groceries, too. (Including peanut butter for your raging peanut butter and jelly addiction.)